NIMBLEDINGO

Paid Search Diagnostics

Google Ads Campaign Not Working? A Diagnostic Order

Spending on Google Ads but not winning jobs? Work through campaign targeting, conversion tracking and location settings in the right order.

By Chris Sarchet Bell17 November 202610 min read
A matte-black megaphone lying on its side on a dark surface, with a thin matte green band around the rim of its mouth, set against a black background.

Paying for Google Ads and not getting work out of it is one of the most frustrating positions an owner-run business can be in. The money leaves the account every day, the dashboard shows activity, and the phone stays quiet. The temptation is to start pulling levers: raise the budget, lower the budget, pause the campaign, rewrite the ads, or hand the whole thing to someone else.

Almost none of that helps, because "not working" is not one problem. It is three, and they have completely different fixes. Before you change a single setting, work out which one you have.

The three versions of "not working"

No clicks. Your ads are barely serving. Impressions are low, clicks are lower, and you are not actually spending much. This is a reach and eligibility problem: budget, bids, ad approval status, keyword volume or an audience narrowed down to almost nobody.

Clicks but no conversions. The money is going out. People are landing on your site. Nothing is coming back. This is either a tracking problem (the enquiries exist but are not being counted) or a relevance problem (the clicks are real but the people clicking were never going to hire you).

Conversions but no jobs. The dashboard says fifteen conversions. You had two phone calls. This is nearly always a measurement problem, and it is the most expensive one, because Google’s automated bidding is optimising towards a signal that is not real.

The order of investigation matters. Check tracking first, because every other number in the account depends on it. Then check what searches you are actually buying. Then check where in the country those clicks came from.

Step one: prove conversion tracking is actually firing

Do not touch keywords, bids or budgets until you know the conversion data is honest. If tracking is broken, every optimisation you make is based on fiction.

Open your conversion actions in Google Ads and look at the status of each one. The statuses are blunt and useful. "Recording conversions" means data is coming in. "No recent conversions" means the tag exists but nothing has fired lately. "Inactive" or "Unverified" means Google has not seen that tag work at all.

Read the Diagnostics tab, not a browser extension

Open the individual conversion action and go to the Diagnostics tab rather than relying on Tag Assistant telling you the tag is present. Tag Assistant confirms that a tag loaded and fired in your browser, on your device, in that moment. That is a very low bar. It does not tell you whether Google Ads is successfully attributing those conversions to real ad clicks, whether consent settings are stopping the data from being used, or whether the tag is firing on a page nobody arrives at after an enquiry.

The Diagnostics tab is reading the actual data Google received over recent weeks, which is the only version that affects your bidding. Work down the checks it surfaces. It will flag whether the tag has been detected on the site at all, whether tag firing has dropped recently compared with the previous period, whether click identifiers are reaching the tag so conversions can be matched to clicks, and whether consent mode or cookie settings are restricting measurement. A recent drop in tag firing with no corresponding drop in traffic is the clearest possible signal that something on the site changed and broke the tag.

Treat a clean Diagnostics tab plus a successful live test as your baseline. Treat a green tick in a browser extension as nothing much at all.

The broken setups that look fine

The form tag fires on page load. The most common one. The conversion tag sits on the thank-you page but is set to fire when the page opens rather than on a submission event, and the thank-you page is reachable by direct URL or gets crawled. Or worse, the tag was placed on the contact page rather than the thank-you page, so every visitor who lands on the form counts as an enquiry. If your conversion count is suspiciously close to your click count, this is why.

Calls are not tracked at all. For a trade, this is the big one. A plumber’s enquiries come by phone. If the only conversion action in the account is a web form, the account will show a handful of conversions a month while the phone rings off the hook, and the bidding algorithm will steer away from the very searches that generate calls. There are three separate things to set up and people usually have none or one of them: calls from the ad itself (via a call asset or call-only ad), calls from the website number after an ad click (which requires the number to be swapped by the Google forwarding script), and clicks on a tel: link on mobile.

Business Profile calls and messages are invisible to Ads. Enquiries that arrive through your Google Business Profile listing, including messages, are not automatically Google Ads conversions. If you are judging the campaign by total enquiry volume across everything, you are mixing two channels. Separate them, or you will cut a campaign that is working and keep one that is not.

Duplicate conversions. The reverse problem. The tag has been placed twice, usually once hard-coded in the theme and once through Google Tag Manager, so every submission counts as two. Or the conversion action is set to count "Every" conversion rather than "One", so someone refreshing the thank-you page three times becomes three leads. Check the counting setting on every lead action. For an enquiry, it should almost always be One.

The caching and page builder trap

Here is the failure that catches well-built sites. You place the conversion tag on the thank-you page. It works. Three months later, nothing is being recorded, and nobody changed anything.

What happened is that a caching plugin, an optimisation plugin or a page builder update started minifying, deferring or stripping inline JavaScript. Scripts get combined into a single file, or deferred until after the user has already navigated away, or removed entirely from a cached copy of the page. The visitor sees an identical thank-you page. The tag never runs.

This is quiet, and it is persistent, because it only affects a page your team almost never loads themselves. Submit a genuine test enquiry through the live site, from a real browser, on mobile as well as desktop, and confirm the conversion appears in the account. Then repeat that test any time you update a caching, security or builder plugin. It takes five minutes and it is the single highest-value habit in a self-managed Ads account.

Step two: read the search terms report

Once you trust the data, find out what you are actually buying.

Keywords are not searches. With broad match, a keyword like "emergency plumber" can serve against queries about plumbing apprenticeships, DIY tutorials, plumbing supply wholesalers and people searching for a plumber in a city you have never worked in. Smart Bidding is supposed to filter this, but it can only do that if it has a reliable conversion signal, which takes us straight back to step one. Broad match plus broken conversion tracking is the most reliably wasteful combination in paid search.

Open the search terms report, set the date range to the last 30 days, and sort by cost descending. Read the list honestly. For each term, ask whether you would quote on that job. Then do the arithmetic that most advertisers never do: add up the spend on every term you would not quote on. That total is what the absence of a negative keyword list cost you last month, and it recurs every month until you fix it.

Build the negative list from what you find, not from a generic template. The terms that waste money for a sparky are different from the ones that waste money for a concreter. Typical categories worth excluding include job and training searches, "free", "DIY", "how to", "near me" variants pointing at other towns, supplier and wholesale searches, and the names of large national competitors you will never outbid. Add negatives at the campaign or shared list level so they apply everywhere.

If the report is largely clean and you are still getting no enquiries, the problem has moved downstream to the landing page or the offer, not the targeting.

Step three: check where the clicks are coming from

This is the setting that quietly drains budget for service-area businesses, and it is buried.

In each campaign’s location settings there is a location options choice. Presence or interest means your ads can show to people who are in your targeted area, regularly in it, or who have shown interest in it. Presence means people who are in or regularly in your targeted area. For a trade with a van and a service radius, Presence is what you want. Presence or interest will serve your ads to someone in another state reading about your town, and you will pay for that click at full price.

Google has historically defaulted new campaigns to the broader option, so plenty of accounts are running it without anyone having chosen it.

Change it, and then be clear about what the change does. It only applies going forward. It does not retrospectively filter your reporting, it does not refund anything, and it does not reset your campaign averages. If you look at a 90-day view a week later and the cost per conversion still looks awful, that is because 83 of those days ran on the old setting. Compare the period after the change against the period before it, as separate date ranges, and give the new period enough volume to mean something before you judge it.

To confirm where clicks genuinely came from, build a custom report. Go to the reporting section, start a report on your campaign, and add the User Location column alongside clicks and cost. User Location is the physical location of the person who clicked. There is a second, similar column called Location of interest, which is the place they were searching about. Those two columns disagreeing is exactly the symptom you are looking for. If User Location shows meaningful spend from regions you do not serve, you have found your leak.

While you are in there, check the radius itself. A 50 kilometre radius drawn from a suburb can easily cross into areas you would never drive to, and excluded locations can be layered on top to carve out the parts of the map you do not want.

Working through it in order

The discipline is the point. Tracking first, because it determines whether any other number means anything. Search terms second, because that is where broad match spend disappears. Location third, because it is a single setting that can undo good work everywhere else. Only then do you touch bids, budgets and ad copy.

If you work through all three and the campaign genuinely is serving relevant searches, in the right area, with honest conversion tracking, and you still are not winning jobs, the problem has moved past the ad platform. At that point you are looking at response time, quoting process and what happens to an enquiry after it arrives, which is a different diagnosis entirely and often a more valuable one. Our guide to choosing a lead generation agency in the UK covers how the pieces either side of the ad account should fit together.

Fixing an Ads account is usually less about clever optimisation and more about removing the things quietly breaking it. If you would rather have the diagnosis, the tracking rebuild and the follow-up handled as one system than keep auditing it yourself between jobs, take a look at Nimble Dingo’s AI growth systems and see whether that is a better use of your week than another evening in the search terms report.

Frequently asked questions

Why does my Google Ads campaign show conversions but no new jobs?

Usually the conversion action is counting something that is not a real enquiry. A form tag that fires on page load, a duplicate tag counting one submission twice, or a conversion set to count every conversion instead of one per click will all inflate the number. Check what the conversion action actually measures before you trust the figure.

Why does my conversion action say 'Inactive' in Google Ads?

Inactive means Google Ads has not received a conversion from that action for an extended period. It often means the tag was never placed, was stripped off the page by a caching or builder plugin, or that calls and messages were never created as conversion actions in the first place.

Should I use Presence or Presence or interest for location targeting?

For a local trade, Presence is almost always the right choice. It limits your ads to people who are regularly in or currently in your targeted area. Presence or interest also includes people who have merely shown interest in the location, which means paying for clicks from well outside your service area.

Does fixing location targeting recover the money I already wasted?

No. Targeting settings only apply going forward, from the moment you change them. Past clicks are already paid for and past data still reflects the old setting, so compare performance by date range rather than assuming the account average has reset.

How do I confirm where my Google Ads clicks actually came from?

Build a custom report on the campaign and add the User Location column. User Location reports the physical location of the person who clicked, which is the figure that matters for a trade with a defined service radius.

Message us